Written by the TreasureGuide for the exclusive use of the Treasure Beaches Report.
![]() |
| Fort Pierce South Beach Tuesday Morning (above) and Afternoon (below). From Surfguru.com. |
This morning is windy with some rain in the area. the surf has picked up some, and some erosion has begun.
---
A couple days ago I started a series on discrimination. I often recommend digging every thing so you won't miss anything. But you will always miss something. Your coil coverage might not be perfect. Some of the time targets will be too deep to be detected. And there are always the areas that you didn't detect.
So far, I've talked about different ways you might use your detector to discriminate. You use audio signals and tones, and you might use conductivity numbers, or you might use additional target ID displays like that provided by the Manticore, but there are other ways besides those to discriminate.
Did you know there was once a metal detector that had a switch to turn on surface blanking. It attempted to silence signals that from targets that were on or very near the surface. I think that was thought to be useful when someone was hunting an area where junk would litter the surface while desirable older targets were deeper. I suspect it simply blanked out blaring audio signals that were produced by larger or shallow items. It attempted to discriminate by stratigraphy.
Seldom using discrimination of any type in those days, I never used the function enough to assess how effective it was. The detector I'm talking about was the Tesoro Royal Sabre.
You can discriminate based upon depth whether your detector provides a function for it or not. You can use the audio signal to assess depth or the detectors depth reading. I talked about that at least once in an old post. Some beach layers can be more productive than others.
What I've talked about so far, is the various types of information a metal detector might provide to help you make dig or no dig decisions, but some of the most useful will come from a knowledge of what is "likely" in the ground where you are metal detecting. That knowledge can come from pervious hunts at the site, doing a little sampling with your detector, observation of the area and what is going on there or other forms of research.
Discrimination efficiency can be improved by such knowledge and a risk/reward assessment. Some junk is more costly, and some good targets are way more valuable than others. That is why I in the previous posts I showed the illustrations related to target values and the relationship between target rarity and values.
If you are hunting a site that you've never detected before, very often you will still have a reason for being there. You believe there is some chance (probability) that good targets may be present. Maybe you didn't give as much thought to what junk might be there.
If you look around, you might suspect certain kinds of junk. If it is a picnic area or you see beer drinkers, you would reasonably expect things like pull tabs and/or bottle caps. Instead of immediately deciding to eliminate everything like that, you might do a little sampling for a while to see if those items are really present, and if so, the type and relative number. If you start detecting with broad ranges of discrimination, you might be discriminating much more than necessary. When you hit a few items - maybe pull tabs - check the signal and display they produce. That will help you fine tune your discriminating. There is little value and some risk in discriminating items that are not there or are present in very low quantities.
The environment will also your discrimination decisions. If target recovery is difficult and time consuming there is more cost in digging junk than if target recovery is easy, like in a dry sand area.
If you decide to discriminate, you don't need to overdo it. There is no need to discriminate what isn't there and that might cost you good targets.
A beach has a target profile. It might have many low value targets, like coins or maybe cheap jewelry, it might produce old stuff or it might produce little but a few really high value targets. Those are just a few very general examples. If you hunt a site repeatedly, you'll get to know it well and get a better of idea of the target profile and what to expect - not only good targets but also junk. That will help you fine tune your discrimination decisions and strategies.
On my recent WV hunt, I had a good idea about what to expect. I knew there were many old items, including both old iron, old coins and other old items, as well as a couple hundred years of other targets both junk and good, but I expected relatively low value targets.. That helped me decide what to discriminate and focus on digging given the restrictive time restraints and considering the difficulty and cost of target recovery. It was tough digging. That is just one example of a hunt where I decided to use a good bit of discrimination. The next time I hunt the site my discrimination strategy might be different depending upon any of a variety of factors. Each time I hunt it, I get a better idea of the junk and good target distribution.
You might develop a mental target profile. It might look something like the histogram below. Each type of junk might be represented along horizontal scale with the prevalence on the vertical scale maybe running from something like 1 to 100.
Besides frequency profile for various types of finds, you will want to factor in find values. It makes a lot more difference if you miss a very high value target, while you won't regret so missing low value targets so much.
When targeting certain kinds of finds, you will consider both the expectations and the values. Would you rather find a bunch of low value targets of scarce high value targets. That depends to some extent upon your nature. For example, are you patient? Do you need occasional positive results to keep from getting frustrated? And for junk, how difficult (or costly) is target recovery, and what is your junk tolerance?
This can all be quantified. If you were focused on gold rings, for example, you could compare one site that on average produces gold rings of X average value every Y hours of hunting, versus another site that produces a different average value. If one site, on average produces one gold ring having an average value of $100 dollars, and another site produces very high value targets, say $1000 dollars on average, you can compute the expected value per hunt for the different sites.
Discrimination is often justified as saving time. For me, it is really questionable how much time it saves. I've noticed that detectorists use a lot of time trying to get a good reading in order to make the dig/no dig decision. In my opinion, it can actually be quicker to dig junk targets under some circumstances. For example, on my recent hunt, one very common junk item was a particular type of pull tab. In most cases one sweep of a foot removed the overburden of leaves and exposed the pull tabs consuming not much more than a very few seconds. I therefore occasionally quickly uncovered the suspected pull tabs to verify the reading and to make sure that it wasn't something else actually giving a similar readout. It is an unfortunate fact that gold can appear almost anywhere on the conductivity scale.
What I'm suggesting today is that a site will have a target profile and you can improve your understanding of that profile as you collect more information. That will help you make discrimination decisions more precisely and effectively.
The relative probability of targets and the value of those targets can be quantified in a way that will help you improve strategies and decisions. That goes for junk targets too, except you weigh the cost, which involves the time it takes under different circumstances as well as the risk of missing good targets.
Never forget the information value of junk. That is something I've talked about in the past.
When beach hunting, for example, a bunch of aluminum or lead objects can tell you something about the distribution of good targets. It might say, don't spend your time here, or really focus on this spot. The same goes for other types of sites. Things like a horseshoe or spike can provide important information too.
---
The next couple of days, we'll have a rougher surf, but it like today, the angles might not be great.
Good hunting,
Treasureguide@comcast.net.


